Sometimes marketing can lead to misconceptions and even wrong information. While creating many church designs and buildings over the years, we encountered some mistaken beliefs by church leaders about pre-engineered metal buildings. These structures are often marketed as a cost-effective, quick solution for large spaces. However, the truth is that while they can offer savings in some situations, they are not always the silver bullet they’re made out to be.
Here’s a breakdown of when pre-engineered metal buildings might make sense for church design, and more importantly, when they do not. By understanding the nuances of this type of construction, church leaders can avoid costly mistakes and ensure that their projects stay on track and within budget.
When Pre-Engineered Metal Buildings Work
Pre-engineered metal buildings (PEMBs) can make sense when a large, open space is required—particularly spaces without internal columns. For instance, if your church design involves a large sanctuary or multi-purpose room over 5,000 square feet, PEMBs can provide a clear span, meaning that there are no columns obstructing the view or the flow of the space.
These buildings also tend to be most cost-effective when their design remains simple—think squares or rectangles. Adding complexity to the design, such as octagons, and other varied shapes, can quickly erode the cost savings that PEMBs are known for. Simple roof designs, such as low-sloped, gable roofs or single-slope roofs, are needed to keep the labor and material costs low. When the roof pitch becomes steeper or features additional design elements like valleys, hips, or dormers, costs increase dramatically.
Common Misconceptions About Pre-Engineered Metal Buildings
There are several misconceptions about PEMBs that are caused by aggressive marketing. One of the most prevalent is that these buildings can save up to 50% in costs compared to traditional construction. Unfortunately, this is not true. While the initial material costs for PEMBs might be lower, you still need to consider other essential elements like foundations, concrete floors, and interior walls. These additional costs can rapidly add up.
Another misconception is that PEMBs are quick and easy to install. While it’s true that simple structures can be erected relatively quickly, more complex designs can face long lead times. Church leaders who expect a fast turnaround may be disappointed when they realize that certain customizations, permits, and inspections can delay the project. Moreover, the idea that these buildings can be disassembled and resold is often misleading. While it’s possible, the reality is that most PEMBs are designed for specific sites and conditions, making them difficult to repurpose for a different location or layout.
The Importance of Infrastructure
One of the most overlooked aspects of church building projects, particularly those involving PEMBs, is the need for adequate infrastructure. It’s important to remember that no matter how much you save on the shell of the building, you’ll still need to meet local building codes and invest in an HVAC and electrical system, plumbing, and utilities to support the structure.
For example, a church we worked with purchased a low-cost pre-engineered building, thinking they had secured a great deal. However, when the contractor began erecting the church building, they realized that the PEMB package didn’t include the necessary wall and roof panels to meet local codes for wind, and snow loads. This resulted in unexpected costs and delays, ultimately negating any initial savings they thought they were getting. The lesson here is clear: a low upfront cost doesn’t always translate to overall savings.
While pre-engineered metal buildings can be an good option for certain church designs, they’re not a one-size-fits-all solution. Working with a church design-build company like the McKnight Group is the best way to help you carefully evaluate the options. Be sure to reach out to us with your questions. We also invite you to join our free i3 webinars, where we dive deeper into the topics of church building and design. Visit our website to learn more and to sign up.